The charges against socrates essay 640 words bartleby. Key ideas in the apology old charges against socrates. Well i assume the older charges against socrates were that of. Plato and xenophon each wrote an apology to defend socrates against the charges on which he was brought up. Smith ar n9a of platos apology, socrates begins his defense against what. What, according to socrates, is the virtue or excellence of a juror. And first, i have to reply to the older charges and to my first accusers, and then i will go on to the later ones. The first charge brought against him is that he was corrupting the youth. And they are many, and their charges against me are of. The name of the dialogue derives from the greek apologia, which translates as a defense, or a speech made in defense. Do his arguments show that he is not guilty of the charges.
Notes on platos apology of socrates humanities commons. The apology is one of four dialogues written about this mostfamous trial. The year in which socrates was prosecuted, 399, was one in which several other prominent figures were brought to trial in athens on the charge of impiety. This argument identified socrates with the sophists.
And when socrates endeavoured, by true reason and examination, to bring these things. In the apology, socrates says this about his charges i am using the translation from the perseus project 1. Socrates defenseor apologia, in ancient greekbegins after his accusers have read the deposition outlining the charges against him. In his book the apology, the greek philosopher plato provides a version of socrates speech during his trail a courtroom in athens. The charges against socrates the charges against socrates were brought upon him by a man names meletus. In battles it often becomes clear that one might escape death, at least, by letting go of his arms and turning around to supplicate his. It may have sprung either from his religious fanaticism or his anger over socrates s association with the thirty tyrants. The first charges against socrates arose from general prejudices that surrounded him over the years. Apology 380 bc an account of socrates defense of himself during his trial for impiety and the. The greek philosopher plato was one of socrates star pupils, and his evidence against socrates is given in the essay the apology of socrates, which includes a dialogue that socrates presented at his trial for impiety and corruption. In the socrates apology, the socrates is charged against the following. In his speech, socrates targets the jurors, the judge, and all of the spectators in the crowd.
Pdf the formal charges against socrates researchgate. What are the new and old charges brought against socrates in apology. Socrates the perceived fragility of athenian democracy. Under questioning, meletus says that he is a complete atheist. Socrates is parodied as the worst kind of sophist who, at his school the thinkery, turns an.
Although in none of platos dialogues is plato himself a conversational partner or even a witness to a conversation, in the apology socrates says that plato is one of several friends in the audience. Socrates, a wise m an, a student of all th ings in the sky and below the earth, who makes the worse. Socrates defense against charges of heresy or atheism a contradictory accusations socrates asks meletus one of the accusers whether he thinks that s. Accounts of what socrates might have said at the trial in his own defense vary. What are the new and old charges against socrates in the.
The charge of investigating things beneath the earth and in the skies belongs to a physicalists like thales and. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In this way plato lets us know that he was an eyewitness of the trial and therefore in the best possible position to write about it. Socrates defense against corrupting the young in platos. Thus, in the apology, socrates attempts to defend himself and his conductcertainly not to apologize for it. The famous athenian philosopher socrates was charged with two specific crimes. Socrates busies himself studying things in the sky and below the earthhere, socrates is charged with concerning himself with inappropriate topics of study he replies by challenging anyone to testify to having seen him professing knowledge about these things. Second charge is being responsible for teaching people to disbelieve the gods. Platos account of socrates defense elucidates some main principles of the socratic philosophy. There are two sets of accusations made against socrates. The indictment against socrates is recorded by diogenes laertius in his lives. It all goes back to the oracle of delphi, where it said that socrates was the wisest man. The following lecture notes on platos apology have been prepared.
For my part, even i nearly forgot myself because of. Meletus has stated that socrates is a doer of evil in that he corrupts the youth, does not believe in the gods of the state, and has introduced new divinities of his own. It may have sprung either from his religious fanaticism or his anger over socratess association with the thirty tyrants. The apology of socrates, by plato the project gutenberg edition trans.
Plato, being socrates wrote the apologetics to show how the great philosopher defended himself against the charges brought to the court by his accusers around 399 bc. This charge identifies s as a natural philosopher early societies are called archaic or originary societies in these societies people make sense of the world and themselves in terms of the gods and by telling stories about the gods. What is the old charge and how does socrates defend himself. Specifically, the apology of socrates is a defence against the charges of. Studying the skies and below the earth studying divine matters as physical science charges brought against socrates new 1. Having made his defense against the first class of his accusers, socrates proceeds to reply to the specific charges that are now being made against him. The first charges against socrates arose from general prejudices that. What are the benefits and costs of the socratic challenge for us.
In this section, socrates addresses the charges leveled against him by his old accusers. A doric temple of 5th century bc charges of the older accusers and. How are the demands socrates places on the jury related to his claim that he is only concerned with saying whats just or not. As he tells us right away, these accusations derive from two main sources, two generations of accusers. Aristophanes also characterizes socrates as charging a fee for his services. Recap of the apology so far socrates begins his defense by defining two sets of charges. Get an answer for how did socrates defend himself against the charges brought against him. Fowler translation, loeb 19 edited with introduction and notes by e. Platos apology and charges against socrates religion essay.
The charges against socrates in the apology powerpoint. Old he studies things in the heavens and below the earth c. Garvin 20 introduction it would not be possible to overestimate the importance of socrates in the development of the. First there was a group of older men who had always.
In the apology, socrates examines the charges brought against him by meletus and tries to prove that they are false. Introduction to philosophy the charges against socrates in the apology two sets of accusations the first thing justice demandsis that i defend myself from the first false accusations made against me and from my first accusers, and then from the later accusations and the later accusers apol 18a the first group of accusers many people. One of the charges in the affidavit written by meletus against socrates is that he is corrupting the youth. Within the duration of this document, i will be discussing the charges laid against socrates and how he attempted to refute the charges.
That is to say, the apology will become socrates answer to the question. Pick one of the new charges and explain in detail how he argues against it. How did socrates defend himself against the charges. Be cause these older accusations are the more dangerous, he undertakes. For of old i have had many accusers, who have accused me falsely to you during many years. What are the specific charges brought against socrates, and why do you think he was so charged. As was mentioned earlier, one great source of these prejudices against socrates comes from aristophanes the clouds, in which socrates is portrayed as an eccentric old fool who floats about suspended from a crane, spouting all sorts of nonsense about the heavens and the earth. And first, i have to reply to the older charges and to my first. Socrates is guilty of wrongdoing in that he busies himself studying things in the sky and below the earth. The trial of socrates 399 bc was held to determine the philosophers guilt of two charges. Old charges against socrates the old charge against me. For socrates and plato, though, this was much more a matter of duty than rights. This video focuses on platos dialogue, the apology, and examines socrates arguments, in his crossexamination of meletus and address to the jury, defending himself against charges of corrupting. Platos apology of socrates how you, men of athens, have been affected by my accusers, i do 17a not know 1.
Socrates speech, however, is by no means an apology in our modern understanding of the word. As such, apology is only a partial document of the entire trial, though socrates meticulously addresses each of his detractors arguments, thereby making it easy to intuit what theyve said about him. Socrates, a wise man, a student of all things in the sky and below the earth, who makes. Meletus motivation in bringing charges against socrates is a matter of considerable debate. I now for the first time come before a court of justice, though more than seventy years old.
Meletus was a young man that socrates did not know very well. Philosophy, religion, and the gods in the origins of liberal education roger barrus. Apologia socratis, written by plato, is a socratic dialogue of the speech of legal selfdefence which socrates spoke at his trial for impiety and corruption in 399 bc. What is the importance of socrates asking the jury to excuse his manner of speaking.
First thing that socrates is charged against by the jury is his refusal to believe in gods whom the state believes in. It is also possible that he was to some degree upset with the low opinion of socrates for poets. Powerpoint slides which work through the various charges against socrates in the apology for an undergraduate introductory class in philosophy. Old he makes the worse argument into the stronger argument b. What was the charge against socrates for which he had to commit suicide by drinking a cup of hemlock. This is an old charge against socrates, revived by meletus socrates has two replies to this charge. Now so far as the accusations are concerned which my first accusers made against me referring to rumor, calumny, and public opinion. As a current student on this bumpy collegiate pathway, i stumbled upon course hero, where i can find study resources for nearly all my courses, get online help from tutors 247, and even share my old projects, papers, and lecture notes with other students.
186 814 537 1436 327 1096 147 40 1157 1144 661 1217 204 1420 1110 1156 518 48 1223 1009 232 333 919 402 677 1160 103 1241 901 178 1057 547 119 663 962